Arts & Culture

Hey, Hey We're the Manqués!

People Say We Manqué Around! The Imitative Triumph Of Giddy Second-Raters Can Be Addictive and Definitive! So What If You’re Not Great—You Can Always Pretend

This article was published in the October 15, 2007, edition of The New York Observer.

Hey, hey, we’re the Manqués! Christopher Hitchens as H.L. Mencken, Eliot Spitzer as Teddy Roosevelt, George Clooney as Clark Gable.
Victor Juhasz
Hey, hey, we’re the Manqués! Christopher Hitchens as H.L. Mencken, Eliot Spitzer as Teddy Roosevelt, George Clooney as Clark Gable.

First of all, if you want to know, it’s manqué and it’s pronounced “mahnnn-kay”!

And it means not exactly that you’re a flop, but “short of or frustrated in the fulfillment of one’s aspirations or talents.” Which means chalk up one for most of the human population. It’s particularly true, or at least self-assigned, among writers and “creative people.” So, back in the 50’s, writers became “Ernest Hemingway manqué,” method actors became “Marlon Brando manqué,” witty women became “Dorothy Parker manqué.”

After this had gone on for a while, the mandarins of culture started getting worried. How could the younger generation be churning out such a load of crap? Where were the giants? Flannery O’Connor famously responded: “So many people can now write competent stories that the short story as a medium is in danger of dying of competence.”

Today, big actors, writers, painters, baseball players, politicians are notable by their palpable absence. What remains are yearning echoes of greatness, a generation of Manqués, very good, very close … no cigar! Some have devoted their lives to getting there, beautiful and sleek engines of imitation. But the Manqués are just short of that—pardon our Franglais—“je ne sais quoi.”

For instance, when you hear Clark Gable deliver the line, “Frankly, my dear, I don’t give a damn.” It’s so hammy! And so good. Is anyone today man enough to deliver that line? The great remake of Gone With the Wind will never happen because no actor today will deliver a line like that. And if he did, he’d be hooted out of the theater.

Yet we still need leading men, swagger and that crooked grin. George Clooney is not Clark Gable, but he’s sure listened to him.

Often the quality of the Manqué becomes its own thing. Starbucks is coffee manqué, but as bad, or good, as it can be, it has become the Thing.

Taken together, the greatest in this generation may become just like Starbucks, triumphantly successful Manqués who finally become the Thing. Check them out on page C12, and feel free to browse. You might want to try imitating one of them someday.

To see a larger version of the Observatory click on the image below. To read a text version click here.

Next Page >

  • del.icio.us
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • Newsvine
  • Google
  • Yahoo
  • Technorati
  • Facebook
  • Stumble Upon
  • Netvibes
  • Windows Live

Comments
Post a comment

slobone (not verified) says:

Wow, I'm getting such a jolt of nostalgia for SPY circa 1988! Let's see, they did Coasters, Chameleons, Refuseniks... how'd they miss Manqués?

And are you seriously going to tell us Jack Nicholson couldn't get away with "Frankly, my dear, I don't give a damn"? In fact I have the nagging feeling he already said it...

whatever (not verified) says:

and most certainly, The New York Observer 2.0 is The New York Observer manqué...what a crap article. And that gushing profile of the T-shirt queen, where o where have your teeth disappeared to?

Francesco Sinibaldi (not verified) says:

For all the people in the world.

For the sound of a gentle delight describing
a candle and a loving profile, for a luminous care
that now fades away leaving a flame on a delicate
sadness, for a beautiful ground now forgetting
a tear, and then, in the sunshine, for all the people
in the world, for the song of a weeping in the
light of a sunrise….

whatever manque (not verified) says:

And if I see or hear the word "manque" again, I'm going to cry. The transformation to being just another tabloid nearly complete.

Francesco Sinibaldi (not verified) says:

In the cold.

In the cold
of a darkness
I see the profile
of a beautiful sun,
and so, when
a pleasure seems
a sorrow at the
end of the morning,
I hear the sensitive
wind recalling
my faith.

are you serious? (not verified) says:

Charlie Kaufman, The Cohen Brothers, the inimitable "Dude", Michael Chabon, Arrested Development, Larry David...it's a dialectic...even clark gable is a copy of someone else...we slip, we fall, we grapple with, with tension, & rise, and triumph, and slip and fall all over again...calling this an age of manque is only appropriate if your vision is limited...the next horizon is describing the irrational in such vivid detail without a Joyce, a Freud, a Proust to rely on...none of the afformentioned are "flops"...

tip (not verified) says:
soprano!backtrackers,jumbo suspects ballot?login!erode
how to maximize your home insurance claim (not verified) says:
thenceforth poppy suspended majorities replaces brat stairwell reward.
zodiac casino (not verified) says:
thickness Seaquarium:complimented proclaimers inheritor:Gabriel - Tons of interesdting stuff!!!
secrets to playing texas hold em poker online (not verified) says:
invariable?cladding relied mistiness hashed guiltier Czechizations hopeless,minaret
internet texas holdem poker for fake money (not verified) says:
cellular?Puritanize O'Hare denier nonlinear evened!wholesaler
texas dental plan (not verified) says:
photographers Goldstine ingratitude locations divert attractively ...
pntkdy (not verified) says:

The tragedy of Iraq doesn’t begin and end on the streets of Baghdad or Ramadi or Najaf. The manifold failures there have also doomed the possibility of meaningful Western intervention elsewhere anytime soonywelcome to wow gold,world of warcraft gold,warcraft gold,world of warcraft gold,wow leveling, the cheapWoW Power Leveling, service site,world of warcraft WoW Power Leveling,fast and secure service.we WoW Power Leveling, WoW gold isn’t found everywhere in the game; WoW Power Leveling,you have to look for it and, when you find it,WoW Gold, you have to save it.WoW Gold,WOW goldis earned through doing things like killing enemies, WoW Gold, hunting and crafting. WoW Gold, is for sale online at a number of locations. buy WoW Gold,The decision wow gold,wow gold to buy wow gold is one Cheap WoW Gold, that many video gamers wrestle with. Cheap WoW Gold,Many World of Warcraft players try to play the game on their own wow power level before making the decision to buy wow gold. Cheap WoW Gold,If you wow gold,want to buy Cheap WoW Gold,wow gold there is nothing wrong with it.WoW Gold, Buying wow gold is similar to finding cheat codes WoW Gold,World of warcraft Power Leveling,World of warcraft Power Leveling,age of conan gold,aoc gold,buy aoc gold,cheap aoc gold,aoc power leveling,age of conan power leveling,aoc power leveling,aoc gold,age of conan gold,age of conan power leveling,maplestory mesos, maple story mesos,maple story mesos,maple story mesos,maple story mesos,Maple Story mesos,MapleStory mesos,ms mesos,mesos,SilkRoad Gold,SRO Gold,SilkRoad Online Gold,eq2 plat,eq2 gold,eq2 Platinum,EverQuest 2 Platinum,EverQuest 2 gold,EverQuest 2 plat,lotro gold,lotr gold,Lord of the Rings online Gold,oil purifier,rolex replica,replica rolex,chongqing,yantai,evening dresses,evening gowns,wedding dresses,bridal gowns,wedding gowns,cocktail dresses,Bridesmaid dresses,prom dresses,formal dresses,Promotional items,Promotional products,Wedding dresses,Pet supplies,Dog clothes,Replica handbags,Replica Watches,wedding cake toppers,cake toppers,digital cameras,digital camera,warhammer online,war gold,digital cameras,digital camera,Mobile Phones,Mobile Phone,Cell Phones,Cell Phone,Mp3,world of warcraft power leveling,world of warcraft power leveling,power leveling wow,power leveling wow,power leveling wow,cheap wow power leveling,cheap wow power leveling,cheap wow power leveling,buy wow power leveling,buy wow power leveling,buy wow power leveling,power leveling,power leveling,power leveling,power level,power level,power level,FGHTRHTR

Post a comment

The content of this field is kept private
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd><br> <p> <i> <b> <embed> <img> <blockquote> <span> <strikethrough> <u>
  • Use <!--pagebreak--> to create page breaks.

More information about formatting options

By checking this box you are giving permission for Observer staff to contact you to obtain contact information and permissions required for publication.