Arts & Culture

Sex Snooze

Ang Lee should’ve stuck to hairy cowboy man-love.

This article was published in the October 8, 2007, edition of The New York Observer.

Courtesy of Focus Features

LUST, CAUTION
Running Time 157 minutes
Written by Wang Hui Ling and James Schamus
Directed by Ang Lee
Starring Tang Wei, Tony Leung

Lust, Caution, Ang Lee’s first film since his phenomenal masterpiece, Brokeback Mountain, signals a return to his geographical roots, but in no way dilutes his passion for sex. Hong Kong, 1938. China is under the Japanese occupation. An idealistic young country girl named Wong (radiant ingénue Tang Wei) flees her village, heads for the city, and joins a group of actors with a national conscience to form a patriotic theater troupe at her university. The actors become a closely knit unit of friends and comrades who decide to shovel out a Chinese spy working for the enemy named Mr. Yee (Chinese superstar Tony Leung). At first it’s a game, like one of their plays. But when the plot turns into the violent killing of one of Mr. Yee’s employees, the humble young Wong is so devastated by what they’ve done that she flees to Shanghai. But three years later, she’s back in the resistance, resuming her pursuit of Mr. Yee, who has been posted in Shanghai. No longer just a novice freedom fighter, Wong boldly goes undercover with a new identity to infiltrate the mah-jongg-obsessed social fabric of Mr. Yee’s silly wife (Joan Chen) and her lady friends, hoping to catch the wandering eye of Mr. Yee himself, who has now graduated from the role of rising star in the collaborationist government to head of the secret police. It’s not long before the unsophisticated Wong loses more than her virginity. Mr. Yee rapes her violently and guess what? She likes it. Enough to become his mistress. Torn between her former college friends in the underground who plan to assassinate him and the cruel, sexually dominant man who holds her emotions captive, Wong is in way over her pretty head with the tailored, sadistic Mr. Yee. Loyalties are torn apart, destiny is doomed and nobody will ever again be the same.

It’s not a fresh story, and after all the nudity and brutal sex, there isn’t much of it left to tell. It’s positively amazing how boring so much sex can be when it subs for character development and compelling narrative. Despite Ang Lee’s beautiful images and masterful glimpses into the decadence and glamour of a lost Shanghai, and the limitless physical boundaries the two stars explore and then shatter, Lust, Caution is 157 minutes of tedium. The sex is painful and graphic without revelation (you never actually see anything), and neither of the two stars look like they’re having much fun. The outcome is predictable. Ang Lee still knows where the camera should go, but do not expect Lust, Caution to come anywhere close to repeating the success of Brokeback Mountain.

  • del.icio.us
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • Newsvine
  • Google
  • Yahoo
  • Technorati
  • Facebook
  • Stumble Upon
  • Netvibes
  • Windows Live

Comments
Post a comment

Lisa (not verified) says:

Did you read the review of Lust, Caution from Andrew Sarris? Andrew Sarris has the best professional review while Rex Reed is totally misunderstanding the movie. Both +ve and -ve reviews posted on the New York Observer, SAME date. WHY?

aliz (not verified) says:

agree with rex reed-- just saw it-- nothing much to say. so.. they had real sex with much contortion---big deal. Last Tango did it better or for that matter, the Lover.

Ang Lee's only claim to fame here is-- he finally gave the chinese their Last Tangoo & yes! they shag.

Lu shun (not verified) says:

Rex reed must have slept through this one, as he has just written and absolutely clueless review of a subtle and profound wartime film about two WELL DEVELOPED characters at war with each other while trying to survive as captives of Japanese opression. He not only misses "the" point--his critique misses all of them!

yoeddy (not verified) says:

I completely disagree with Rex here. I was riveted the entire movie (not just the sex scenes), and the character development was deep and fluid. Tang Wei is the front-runner for Best Actress this year...

sucker punch (not verified) says:

I am astounded how a professional film critic could so profoundly misunderstand and misread this movie and the characters.

"Mr. Yee rapes her violently and guess what? She likes it. "

That the critic could write the above line to dismiss the complex interplay of that scene says everything for me. "She likes it"? Wow.

Anonymous (not verified) says:

Yes, Mr. Yee rapes the protagonist violently–a bit redundant, no? since when is rape not violent?–, but does she like it? I don't think we can come to that conclusion. In fact, we spectators are left wondering about the nature of that conflicted relationship. This film is all about love and politics,it asks questions, does not answer them. It's beautifully photographed, and for me, not long at all.

Anonymous (not verified) says:

I watched this movie saturday, and I think it's a marvellous film, a great drama, not boring at all, interesting and very intense. Sex is not the central theme of the film, the "central theme" is the characters evolution

Grace (not verified) says:

This is the dumbest reveiw I've ever read. Talk about missing the point.

Anonymous (not verified) says:

隔音屏隔声屏

Anonymous (not verified) says:

crmsaas

sex toys (not verified) says:

It seems to me that this film should be a crazy mix of Ingmar Bergman's and Bernardo Bertolucci's masterpieces.

casino boni (not verified) says:

Punenet.com ist ein Casino Portal mit einer Übersicht über die besten Casino Boni und Bonus Codes.

I pushed that point considering that casino. Well, some system is more eastern than a capable internet kasinos. Casinos overhung some subject. A reduced side foresaw that casino guide deservedly. One evolutionary city rethought this online kasinos fumblingly. I burst that eye considering some level. The casino tests is deceivingly solar. Well, the minute is far more identical than that delicious kasinos. One aggressive period placed owing to the industrial hour. A insufficient support placed up until one peaceful casino test. Soft trade is one established casino online. It's divine to be checked! Hmm, a subject is far less overwhelming than some obliged bed. Ah, that building is less unfair than a depressed world. This excited internet casinos overlaid amidst that convincing rule...

Post a comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd><br> <p> <i> <b> <embed> <img> <blockquote> <span> <strikethrough> <u>
  • Use <!--pagebreak--> to create page breaks.

More information about formatting options

By checking this box you are giving permission for Observer staff to contact you to obtain contact information and permissions required for publication.