We all have our biases, but based on my experience--having worked in the same newsroom as Haner--I have to say that Scocca got this one right. He was full of bluster, but he didn't last long, or leave much of a legacy. And I've never heard or read it put better than Scocca's characterization of broadsheet editors mistaking bombast for "voice." The exception among such writers was Charlie LeDuff. He had real voice, if you ask me.