Should Journalists Face the Music?
A few years back I wrote a tough piece for the Times Magazine about a Blake Edwards' show on Broadway called Victor/Victoria. Edwards had let me hang out with the production as long as I wanted. When I wrote the piece, it was tough on the show. The great Robin Wagner was the set designer. He and I had gotten to be friends and he called me the weekend the magazine came out. He said, "You have to come to the opening of the show, just come in the stage door the way you always do and see everyone." "Oh no," I said. "Don't you understand, you wrote what you wanted to, that's fine, now you have to come see the people you wrote this about. Be a man."
But I didn't do what Robin said because I was a 3-toed lizard.
This is apropos of the squabble between White Sox manager Ozzie Guillen and Chicago Sun-Times columnist Jay Mariotti, in which Guillen called Mariotti a "fag" and was then ordered by Selig to have sensitivity training. One reason Guillen was upset with Mariotti is the guy didn't come into the locker room to talk to the players and manager.
Chicago Tribune columnist Rick Morrissey agrees with Guillen:Let's say I criticize Sox catcher A.J. Pierzynski for something he did in a game. And let's say I do it in the Sunday Tribune, which has a circulation of about 960,000.Isn't it reasonable for Pierzynski to have an opportunity to lash out at me in front of media and teammates in the clubhouse if I've treated him similarly in print? It seems pretty straightforward to me. It's what I was taught to do. It's what nearly all of the columnists in the country do. The honorable thing.
Look, it's not always fun walking into a locker room. Sometimes it's uncomfortable. But it comes with the territory of being a columnist.
I want to offer some exceptions to Morrissey's rule. A journalist should be able to criticize a ballplayer's performance, or George Bush's, without have to talk about it with him. "Showing up" to talk it over is menschy, but it brings up the issue of access and compromise. (Michael Kinsley used to say that profiles of important people should be written without meeting the person—otherwise the journalist just gets charmed and hornswoggled.)
But it's all context. The locker room isn't the White House. Journalists have real power over baseball teams, and theatrical runs. If they're big enough to dish it out, they should be big enough to take it. Morrissey is right on this. And so was Robin Wagner.
wgehtgt says:
k102360 k154635 k164010 k175860 k151560 k145635 k147060 k155385 k120585 k95610 k177210 k107160 k164985 k146910 k97860 k110835 k103035 k173610 k105210 k96885 k149010 k140385 k139710 k162135 k109485 k145260 k116760 k94110 k155535 k164685 k110310 k164460 k96360 k113310 k144960 k170760 k182460 k144660 k121785 k179685 k160635 k166185 k176385 k175560 k137160 k99810 k132510 k159810 k98685 k156585 k178635 k129510 k126135 k104385 k100185 k96285 k117285 k146685 k154035 k135960 k176535 k157260 k146535 k122085 k170385 k164535 k117960 k108060 k164610 k135135 k152310 k175635 k172035 k110460 k143310 k165510 k110385 k112335 k165585 k176835 k101085 k92310 k178110 k108435 k157185 k104685 k163710 k142935 k160260 k131160 k182235 k121185 k183060 k131310 k143385 k152235 k111510 k104010 k126885 k167610 k99660 k132585 k149985 k136485 k170010 k93135 k157785 k171210 k108810 k174210 k140310 k106785 k161610 k99735 k107460 k181035 k97485 k183360 k130035 k167310 k140010 k140685 k164835 k169560 k134010 k102435 k119835 k161310 k147435 k181860 k140760 k109035 k147510 k136785 k155685 k125235 k101160 k165435 k118410 k170535 k152910 k106260 k124860 k107535 k175260 k174285 k139485 k101685 k94785 k169710 k129285 k149160 k122760 k161985 k97260 k177585 k181710 k160485 k182985 k114060 k134610 k108360 k174135 k160710 k152685 k145860 k124335 k137610 k167835 k147210 k104235 k95010 k104835 k143235 k155310 k96810 k147360 k152985 k131535 k150510 k92535 k94410 k128310 k133260 k128085 k129210 k120135 k167160 k168960 k158685 k107235 k154110 k182685 k148635 k169110 k121410 k114210 k165885 k128535 k101910 k117060 k140985 k103560 k113235 k104085 k141735 k125910 k172485 k162585 k146985 k123135 k96585 k163260 k105810 k123585 k159360 k145110 k94935 k124185 k146835 k108510 k106485 k149310 k125310 k166635 k137760 k118335 k154260 k135735 k177960 k134760 k124560 k146160 k138135 k171960 k163785 k93735 k157560 k149685 k127860 k182010 k164085 k124410 k161685 k112410 k154485 k155160 k134460 k176310 k111285 k148410 k178035 k156660 k105060 k163335 k91935 k140085 k127635 k130260 k170610 k155460 k168660 k120360 k113385 k107010 k130710 k102285 k157110 k150885 k131460 k105885 k145560 k176160 k175935 k119010 k128160 k145035 k120735 k97560 k130635 k135210 k111585 k127710 k132210 k182085 k137235 k109335 k133185 k94635 k174810 k111135 k118710 k113535 k148785 k144885 k92160 k110760 k122985 k98085 k161010 k179160 k137535 k144360 k102135 k92835 k152010 k135585 k157335 k108885 k154560 k167235 k113760 k152160 k100560 k105960 k115260 k170235 k163185 k141360 k119085 k95385 k160185 k169785 k143535 k163635 k116835 k151035 k180510 k99960 k99435 k129735 k179460 k168435 k168360 k100485 k96060 k137085 k169485 k168060 k150810 k169935 k93360 k143685 k138060 k124785 k121635 k94710 k147735 k150735 k170460 k111735 k116610 k138210 k158985 k171135 k112185 k95835 k162060 k125610 k136560 k124485 k123210 k139335 k167685 k127560 k151110 k178935 k99060 k165135 k108135 k176985 k148185 k114360 k113835 k138585 k106935 k92910 k141960 k141810 k111435 k173535 k138285 k142485 k125535 k141285 k177360 k100035 k106110 k168135 k151860 k113985 k130185 k132435 k137685 k112710 k100710 k181785 k122235 k172635 k146010 k130785 k128610 k139785 k166785 k167010 k177885 k92085 k153435 k169635 k119385 k162210 k176610 k107310 k152835 k115410 k132735 k120210 k150060 k97035 k139410 k101385 k128235 k143085 k114435 k114735 k163035 k182835 k99510 k141660 k163410 k151935 k116235 k182160 k150285 k133560 k171360 k96135 k173985 k130485 k129660 k156435 k120810 k167085 k180060 k104610 k145935 k158085 k105660 k174510 k93285 k120885 k179985 k127335 k183210 k153060 k134085 k115335 k127785 k125460 k93585 k94860 k125160 k178485 k109785 k180210 k96735 k152610 k96660 k115035 k177285 k99885 k93885 k147660 k171285 k121035 k128835 k109560 k148560 k98385 k155910 k129885 k153210 k155610 k116160 k157485 k141585 k111210 k117735 k139935 k116085 k124935 k165210 k152385 k98235 k106185 k154335 k113910 k168510 k97635 k97785 k135810 k159510 k182310 k134160 k112635 k103860 k108210 k121935 k109860 k140460 k123735 k161535 k159135 k128460 k139860 k178185 k157860 k146085 k110235 k97335 k121335 k154785 k136410 k112260 k167460 k93060 k107985 k168585 k147135 k119910 k164385 k125685 k163860 k164160 k174660 k119610 k174735 k127185 k115485 k116985 k165660 k158460 k170310 k158385 k180660 k178710 k157410 k113685 k145335 k113010 k110610 k144285 k166110 k95910 k110010 k106035 k128910 k137835 k109260 k125760 k163935 k146760 k144435 k181185 k178335 k161910 k152085 k98760 k139185 k151410 k161160 k160035 k100410 k138360 k179535 k122460 k175035 k145710 k158535 k103185 k108585 k136260 k178260 k118485 k112035 k142635 k109410 k158235 k138660 k171585 k122535 k94560 k173010 k104460 k155010 k152535 k176010 k102510 k95085 k111360 k128685 k118260 k118185 k103410 k95160 k117210 k110160 k181485 k115860 k145410 k172185 k144135 k112785 k148260 k129435 k175185 k130410 k142035 k156210 k118560 k109185 k91785 k132285 k173910 k100860 k142560 k144210 k140610 k115935 k128385 k149910 k168210 k179085 k133860 k144510 k101310 k176460 k103110 k179235 k121110 k100335 k109710 k92385 k98160 k134385 k112560 k132360 k155085 k102735 k156510 k162735 k180885 k174360 k141510 k117135 k137310 k165735 k139110 k93510 k107085 k96435 k172410 k129135 k102060 k131235 k133110 k149535 k156960 k150435 k93435 k122610 k170835 k136635 k119760 k180285 k174960 k106635 k151485 k177135 k120060 k174585 k133935 k121485 k116535 k178860 k112110 k108285 k179835 k123285 k156060 k131985 k141885 k121560 k108660 k160410 k145485 k166485 k173460 k151185 k173685 k160110 k102810 k107385 k173160 k153510 k160335 k94260 k125085 k124110 k159285 k122835 k93960 k125010 k114585 k128760 k139035 k119460 k144060 k136185 k161835 k115710 k131085 k127035 k176910 k156285 k171435 k106860 k172785 k125835 k104760 k127410 k119235 k91710 k176085 k157035 k166035 k100785 k139635 k130935 k171660 k153810 k117360 k104985 k168735 k156360 k102585 k174885 k165360 k181635 k98985 k100110 k147585 k138810 k143835 k98835 k159060 k148485 k129810 k149385 k105585 k123960 k92760 k109935 k170085 k123060 k137385 k114285 k148335 k179385 k114135 k143910 k130860 k96510 k150360 k165960 k158610 k160785 k153960 k154860 k107910 k150960 k115785 k138435 k120285 k108960 k169410 k101460 k175410 k164910 k179610 k131610 k102885 k135510 k126510 k180585 k147960 k119310 k102960 k151710 k93660 k139260 k159960 k142410 k101235 k146235 k95310 k156735 k174435 k133710 k161760 k92010 k172110 k167385 k163485 k133785 k136335 k162435 k130335 k181335 k117885 k148710 k105135 k112860 k131835 k124035 k110085 k134310 k182760 k118035 k141135 k100935 k106710 k137985 k125385 k172935 k159210 k181110 k167985 k98460 k153285 k162960 k117435 k102210 k101010 k128985 k176760 k170160 k134835 k107835 k146385 k155235 k96210 k134910 k158760 k150210 k180135 k158160 k152460 k103635 k159435 k149835 k177660 k94485 k103935 k116910 k93810 k146310 k183285 k142335 k171735 k156810 k95535 k170910 k147810 k142785 k177810 k133410 k159660 k114660 k166335 k123435 k129585 k177435 k169260 k158010 k132060 k122685 k154935 k105435 k182535 k119535 k113085 k142110 k166560 k113610 k121260 k114510 k134985 k148035 k120510 k103260 k141435 k98910 k164085 k140160 k126660 k177735 k106410 k110685 k106560 k177510 k163110 k95685 k131910 k152760 k118785 k99135 k171885 k104535 k105285 k162660 k142185 k149235 k164760 k172860 k123885 k126585 k109110 k165060 k153735 k158310 k150135 k155760 k102660 k132810 k98010 k150660 k110910 k144810 k120960 k172560 k162510 k153360 k127260 k165810 k123510 k106335 k162810 k121860 k125985 k148935 k101610 k92235 k93210 k131010 k110535 k151785 k140535 k169185 k135885 k96960 k140235 k180435 k147885 k114885 k153885 k101985 k94185 k173385 k135060 k126285 k151635 k97110 k146610 k156885 k143985 k172710 k136860 k92460 k183135 k158835 k136710 k168285 k119985 k181935 k126810 k154410 k109635 k171060 k173235 k101835 k103485 k142860 k113460 k95760 k155985 k151260 k95985 k162885 k170985 k116685 k159585 k107610 k179910 k182385 k98310 k175785 k126210 k97410 k99285 k127110 k157635 k98535 k103785 k116310 k111810 k149085 k156135 k122010 k161460 k97710 k115560 k144735 k172260 k179010 k154710 k112935 k138735 k181410 k161085 k168885 k94035 k139560 k181560 k161235 k133335 k137010 k108735 k175110 k148110 k166935 k107760 k95460 k116010 k146460 k133035 k142260 k133635 k136110 k122160 k166710 k178785 k143160 k119160 k123810 k105360 k173085 k180735 k117660 k171810 k153585 k100260 k94335 k111960 k123360 k147285 k143610 k135285 k131685 k129360 k134685 k141210 k117585 k118935 k103710 k129960 k167760 k137910 k162360 k114960 k133485 k175710 k142710 k159885 k130110 k99210 k111060 k151335 k113160 k92685 k140910 k136935 k145785 k114810 k143010 k178410 k112485 k132960 k180360 k127935 k117510 k159735 k135360 k169035 k148860 k116460 k180960 k124260 k126060 k181260 k149610 k155835 k127485 k115185 k120435 k166860 k172335 k157710 k169860 k182610 k134235 k100635 k173310 k140835 k92610 k121710 k164310 k97935 k173835 k104910 k126435 k138510 k171510 k170685 k118860 k123660 k138960 k158910 k131760 k122910 k143760 k117810 k115110 k176235 k104160 k116385 k132135 k107685 k143460 k179760 k167910 k144585 k105510 k178560 k137460 k164235 k115635 k126960 k126360 k92985 k182910 k161385 k118635 k119685 k153660 k129060 k180810 k132885 k174060 k177060 k145185 k101760 k101535 k104310 k132660 k135660 k175485 k168810 k149460 k124635 k118110 k154185 k150585 k138885 k141060 k122310 k128010 k111885 k167535 k97185 k99585 k124710 k120660 k176685 k95235 k130560 k111660 k136035 k162285 k160860 k166260 k175335 k153135 k134535 k105735 k157935 k166410 k103335 k160560 k165285 k131385 k169335 k160935 k126735 k149760 k110985 k91860 k135435 k163560 k179310 k122385 k98610 k99360 - reply
- flag this
