Manhattan Music

missing text image: sites/all/themes/obs_2007/img/column-logo-manhattan-music.gif

Articles in Manhattan Music

Nonviolence at the Met; A Boldface Crowd at Zankel Hall

Richard Croft in Philip Glass’ <i>Satyagraha</i> &lt;br /&gt;at the Metropolitan Opera.
Ken Howard/Metropolitan Opera
Richard Croft in Philip Glass’ Satyagraha
at the Metropolitan Opera.

Compared to the publicity blowout that preceded the season-opening production of Lucia di Lammermoor—a wild-eyed Natalie Dessay plastered over dozens of city buses—the Metropolitan Opera’s promotion of the company’s first production of Philip Glass’ 1980 opera, Satyagraha, which opened April 11, was almost restrained.

“Could an opera make us stand up for the truth?” asked one poster. “Could an opera make us warriors for peace?” asked another. (The outdoor campaign was underwritten by Met patron Agnes Varis, a devoted political activist and philanthropist.) If Giuseppe Verdi were around, he would have asked, “Can this opera make money?”—a philosophy that brought forth such trivial entertainments as La Traviata, Aida and Otello, not to mention a piece of fluff called Tristan und Isolde.

I don’t doubt for a moment Mr. Glass’ commitment to the ideals that his opera promotes—it’s an heroic portrait of Mahatma Gandhi in his first years as a defender of the Indian people—but he’s just as much a man of the theater as old Verdi.

Satyagraha (which means “Truth Force” in Sanskrit) has been making money for the same reasons those other operas have: It has something to say, and mostly says it well. Mr. Glass’ brand of minimalism can be maddeningly plain, yet it’s the product of a transformative genius. The operatic creations of John Adams, which the Met will present in future seasons, may be more subtle and dramatically varied, but they’re built on Mr. Glass’ template.

The composer and his librettist, Constance DeJong, adapted a sequence of texts from the Bhagavad Gita into a series of tableaux that depict Gandhi’s struggle to organize oppressed Indian workers in South Africa in the years before the First World War. The action is often static, but then so was Gandhi’s method: his philosophy of nonviolent resistance, which inspired Martin Luther King Jr.

A sumptuous staging would have gone against everything Gandhi stood for. The production team of Phelim McDermott and Julian Crouch—who first crafted their version for English National Opera—therefore made their simple sets out of corrugated metal, with reams of newsprint used as props and bits of décor. (Corrugated metal was used by the colonial powers to build fences and basic structures; Gandhi’s newspaper Indian Opinion helped build support for his cause.) The contributions of a “Skills Ensemble” of aerialists and puppeteers maximized the mythic wonder inherent in the story.

If economy and invention went hand in hand, it was often to the benefit of Mr. Glass, whose music was sometimes too spacious for its own good. (Let’s just say that Act II could use a hefty 10-minute cut.) Perhaps Act III—a tragic tone poem built largely on the alternation of two chords—was the most effective. Dr. King motioned silently from on high; blocks of newsprint, affixed like funeral plaques to a massive wall, were stripped off to reveal television screens showing footage from Bloody Sunday and the March on Washington.

Act III is also largely a duet for tenor and conductor, and it profited from the solid musicality and poignant phrasing of Richard Croft (singing the role of Gandhi) and Dante Anzolini (in his podium debut). In the roles of Miss Schlesen and Mr. Kallenbach, two of Gandhi’s European followers, Rachelle Durkin and Earle Patriarco provided sterling support. The Met Orchestra, used to the subtleties and complexities of Mozart and Wagner, cranked out Mr. Glass’ endless arpeggios with professional dispatch.

 

ONE OF MR. Glass’ biggest fans is the pianist Bruce Levingston, who gathered a glittering audience for his solo recital at Zankel Hall on April 14. Among the crowd, one could spot the distinguished composers Charles Wuorinen and Sebastian Currier, there to hear their music world-premiered; the pianist’s pianists Ursula Oppens and Jerome Lowenthal; the actor Andrew McCarthy; the writer Dana Vachon; and Michael Stipe and David Rockefeller, who need no introduction.

Not everyone had a Platinum card, of course. But what all these boldface names have in common (like the composers Mr. Levingston has championed over the years, a list that includes David Del Tredici, Milton Babbitt, William Bolcom, Lisa Bielawa and Mr. Glass) is that they’re among the best at what they do. It would be a mistake to see Mr. Levingston’s nearly decade-long series of Premiere Commission concerts as fancy social occasions: They’re serious events in which both new and familiar works are presented with a singular combination of challenge and delight.

Mr. Levingston picked pieces that speak to his strengths, which are considerable, and performed on the same carefully voiced Steinway that Alfred Brendel used for his farewell New York recital. The columnar chords of Arvo Pärt’s Für Alina, a seminal work of Baltic minimalism, came through with a remarkable radiance and calm, as did the liquid sequences of a Debussy étude. Mr. Levingston’s New York-premiere performance of the prominent German composer Wolfgang Rihm’s Brahmsliebewalzer, a surreal though loving tribute to the master, allowed his rendition of Brahms’ late Intermezzo in E Major, which immediately followed, to strike our ears with refreshment and wonder.

Both Liszt’s daunting Vallée d’Obermann and Mr. Currier’s absorbing and exquisitely crafted Departures and Arrivals seemed not only played but lived through, musical diaries that seamlessly mixed the composers’ thoughts with those of their interpreter. Composers cherish these kinds of concerts; the Premiere Commission series should go on forever.

 

Russell Platt is a composer and a music editor at The New Yorker. He can be reached at rplatt@observer.com.

About Last Night: Instant Nostalgia for Retro-Futurism Yields Another Moby Album

Moby&#039;s new album,<i> Last Night</i>, hits record stores today.
Getty Images
Moby's new album, Last Night, hits record stores today.

In 1992, Moby was among the bristling avant garde of dance music, at a time when that genre seemed poised to break through to the mainstream in a big way. It was with him that it did break, just a few years later. 1999’s Play, mainly a roster of scratchy blues and gospel samples layered over languid, housey tracks, sold nine million copies worldwide, spawned a series of hits, and introduced us to the ubiquity principle, whereby artists and their albums’ success can be measured by the fact that you hear them everywhere. He was Feist before Feist, “Young Folks” and “Crazy” all rolled into one, somehow pumping out of speakers at the Gap, the Duane Reade, your doctor’s office, your best friend’s cocktail party, and all those Silicon Alley startup parties. Every single track on Play was licensed for commercial use. The future was then.

Like the era of "irrational exuberance" that produced it, that album is likely to be the achievement for which Moby is best remembered, though he recently remarked that “in hindsight, it wasn't fun being the crucified poster child for selling out.”  read more »

Adam Green Scrapes Off the Mold

Sophie Jarry

So there's no way Adam Green could have known that, when asked by director Jason Reitman what music her character ought to listen to, Juno star Ellen Page would reply "The Moldy Peaches" faster than you can say "homeskillet."

And there's no way Mr. Green could have known the film would become such a runaway success, or that a tune by his old band, the Moldy Peaches, featured prominently therein would become one of iTunes' hottest downloads, or that the soundtrack would rocket to the top of the Billboard 200, or that he'd end up reuniting with ex-band mate Kimya Dawson after a four-year hiatus to perform their old songs in front of the ladies on The View, or that thousands of teens across the country would record their own cover versions of Juno's unofficial theme "Anyone Else But You," and then load them up on YouTube.  read more »

Mountain Goats Keep Gaining Altitude With Latest, Heretic Pride

John Darnielle performing in late 2007.
lastyearsgirl via flickr.com
John Darnielle performing in late 2007.

As this decade wanes, some of the chaos in the world of music seems to be settling, as those looking for new sounds grow tired of bottomless discovery. It’s exhausting, really, this omnivorous accumulation of songs. How many albums have been downloaded only to languish somewhere in the catacombs of sprawling hard drives? Yet everything hasn’t devolved into ringtones and novelty singles. The furious dismantling of the pillars of corporate greed (so long, $18.99 CD!) hasn’t hurt enduring grass-roots indie musicians like John Darnielle, who records under the moniker the Mountain Goats. In fact Darnielle’s work, idiosyncratic and acquired-taste though it may be, is more popular than ever, and his latest, perhaps most welcoming album sees him poised to break through to even more new listeners. It’s notable, especially given that he’s been making his music for more than 17 years.  read more »

Mattila’s Manon Misses the Mark; Berio’s Vital, Fractured Sinfonia

Karita Mattila in <i>Manon Lescaut</i> at the Metropolitan Opera.
Ken Howard/Metropolitan Opera
Karita Mattila in Manon Lescaut at the Metropolitan Opera.

Nobody who heard Karita Mattila sing the title role of Strauss’s Salome on the opening night of the Metropolitan Opera’s 2004 production will ever forget it. That she stripped (briefly) nude at the climax of the Dance of the Seven Veils surely helped fuel the fire, but mainly it was stuff of the performance itself, a heady mixture of fearless vocal fireworks and a daringly sexualized dramatic presence. When Ms. Mattila took her bow, a frenzy erupted: Students, scenesters, stockbrokers and socialites were all on their feet, screaming in amazement and delight.

Ms. Mattila was warmly received after the first night of the revival of the Met’s 1980 production of Puccini’s Manon Lescaut (1893) on Jan. 29, but I doubt that her performance will inspire fevered memories. It has been widely reported that the Met is making a new production of Tosca for the magnificent Finnish soprano in the 2009-10 season, and I think she’ll fit the role of the great diva—from the beginning, a petulant and tempestuous character—better than she did the doe-eyed Manon, the pretty, middle-class French teenager who, brought into a life of luxury in pre-revolutionary Paris, cannot help but destroy Des Grieux, the young student who’s besotted with her.

Her beautifully “cool” Nordic sound may be a detriment in shaping a role that demands warm-blooded Italianate tone color and legato, but there’s no reason why a non-Italian singer can’t make a splash as Manon. To my eyes and ears, Ms. Mattila barely registered dramatically in Act I (the superb Dale Travis, as the old roué Geronte, acted rings around her) and gave a rather tarty and brazen Lulu-type characterization—more redolent of Weimar Germany than the ancien régime—in Act II. Only in the two final, tragic acts was the 47-year-old soprano truly convincing, seeming to bring her own experience as an older and wiser woman to the fore.

Her Des Grieux was Marcello Giordani. When he’s good, this tenor is a kind of latter-day Carlo Bergonzi, a singer whose timbre isn’t memorable but whose style and professionalism are an anchor for any production. The Met is asking a lot of him this year: Not only did he sing Edgardo to Natalie Dessay’s Lucia on the season’s opening night, but the house is bringing him back in March to sing the title role in Verdi’s powerful Ernani, which once belonged to Luciano Pavarotti.

I was looking forward to hearing Mr. Giordani sing at the New Year’s Eve Concert at La Fenice in Venice, but he pleaded illness (and was replaced by the sturdier, no-nonsense tenor Walter Fraccaro). During Act I of Manon Lescaut, I feared that Mr. Giordani still had the same Euro-bug in his throat: His singing was messy and frequently off pitch. But in Act II he somehow got hold of his instrument and used it well for the rest of the night.

This opera, so flawed and yet so thrilling, needs younger singers and a fresh production that will get rid of the kitschy early-80’s glamour of the Met’s current staging and burrow down to the fervid passion of the score. If there was a true streak of giovinezza in the performance, it came from James Levine and his wonderful orchestra, who offered sharp rhythms, sinuous phrases and cashmere textures that maximized the ardor of Puccini’s post-Wagnerian idiom.

 

ITALIAN MUSIC IN the 20th century was inevitably altered by the irresistible wave of modernism, but the lyric warmth and theatrical verve of the Italian tradition survived within it, as the long career of Luciano Berio (1925-2003) shows.

It was the New York Philharmonic that premiered Berio’s most famous work, Sinfonia, in 1968. The once-famous Swingle Singers—the smooth, scat-driven a cappella group that helped provide the soundtrack to the Age of Aquarius—took on the eight amplified vocal parts at the premiere. Last week it was the turn of the frighteningly competent Synergy Vocals group from London. Lorin Maazel, seemingly a little weary from all the Wagner he’s been conducting over at the Met recently, led a firm but dispassionate performance on the night I attended (Jan. 31).

Sinfonia, a work that not only uses texts by Claude Lévi-Strauss and Samuel Beckett but that was shaped by contemporary streams of structuralist and semiotic theory, escapes the expressive prison that enclosed so much music of its time—but only just. Johannes Brahms was also a deeply intellectual composer, but in his eloquent Fourth Symphony, which Maazel conducted smartly after intermission, he never let it show. That’s not so easy anymore.

The composer Steven Stucky, who introduced the performances of Sinfonia, maintains that listeners don’t need a special background “to enjoy it.” I disagree: I think you need a background in the late 1960’s, a vital, destructive and fractured time that helped create an atmosphere for a music that shared the same attributes. To enjoy Berio’s collection of 14 Sequenzas for solo instruments, however, you need only have a love of music, a love that a marathon concert at the Rose Theatre on Feb. 2—by Philharmonic musicians and guest artists—would have extravagantly confirmed.

In a style that dispensed with the comforts of regular phrases and tonal centers, Berio offered up music of coloristic variety, polyphonic brilliance and technical innovations that challenge the most virtuosic of performers—and created the finest suite of unaccompanied pieces since Bach. Among the fine performances I was able to hear, I especially enjoyed the ravishing feast of subtle detail that the flutist Robert Langevin brought out in Sequenza I; the cool mastery and charcoal timbre of the pianist Amy Briggs Dissanayake in Sequenza IV; and the sheer endurance in Sequenza XII of the bassoonist Martin Kuuskmann, who gave a sleek and unruffled cohesion to an unruly bear of a piece.

 

Russell Platt is a composer and a music editor at The New Yorker. He can be reached at rplatt@observer.com.

Chan Marshall Grows Up

Chan Marshall.
Wannabes via flickr.com
Chan Marshall.

Everybody needs to stop complaining about Chan Marshall. If I hear another person talk about how she has smoothed over the rough edges that made her so great and eradicated all the warts-and-all charm from her repertoire, I'm going to spit.

Just a year ago, after releasing the strongest album by far of her career, Ms. Marshall, or Cat Power as she's known, cancelled a tour due to a breakdown. Plenty reacted with smug I-coulda-called-it satisfaction given her reputation for stagefright and worse. Then, a few months later, Ms. Marshall emerged stronger, leaner, and meaner than ever, and has since been treating audiences (ever larger, ever more thrilled audiences) to some of the best performances of her life. One review of her new album actually praised her former "paranoid-but-pretty" style in contrast to the strength and poise she now exhibits. You'd think people wanted this woman dead.  read more »

Maazel Makes Sense of Die Walküre; Richard Jones' (Almost) Adult Hansel and Gretel

Alice Coote, Philip Langridge and Christine Schäfer in Engelbert Humperdinck’s <i>Hansel and Gretel</i>.
Ken Howard
Alice Coote, Philip Langridge and Christine Schäfer in Engelbert Humperdinck’s Hansel and Gretel.

January may be a dead time for the movie business, but in New York, at least, classical music snaps back with a vengeance. Last week brought an exceptional head rush, as fond returns and new beginnings crowded the calendar.

At the center of it was Lorin Maazel, who, despite his advanced age—and the critical drubbing he regularly endures—remains the most resilient conductor on the American scene. On Jan. 7, after an absence of 45 years, he returned to the Metropolitan Opera to lead a triumphant revival of Die Walküre.

Three days later, his full-time employer, the New York Philharmonic, announced what promised to be an especially engaging final season for Mr. Maazel, who has been the orchestra’s music director since 2002 and is due to retire in June of 2009. One of the last tasks of Mr. Maazel’s tenure will be to conduct Mahler’s Symphony No. 8, the so-called “Symphony of a Thousand”—the kind of late-Romantic bombast that he revels in.

Last week’s triumph was of a quieter kind—a performance of impressive subtlety and understanding. New York Wagnerites have become used to the James Levine style, an endlessly flowing sound, almost wanton in its luxury, that radiates from deep within the orchestra and can occasionally overwhelm the singers. But Mr. Maazel, whose knowledge of this music matches Mr. Levine’s, immediately put his own stamp on the piece, crafting a sound that was drier and more restrained, gaining in clarity what it lost in color.

With the singers Adrianne Pieczonka, Clifton Forbis and Mikhail Petrenko all excellent and free from strain, Act I became like chamber theater, though of an exceptionally muscular kind. The whole thing made such sense that even the longtime production’s cartoonish sets and costumes lost their tackiness. And in the few moments when Mr. Maazel really let the orchestra go—as in Hunding’s angry condemnation of his dangerous house guest, Siegmund—the effect was all the more powerful for its rarity.

Mr. Maazel’s deliberative approach took some of the excitement out of Acts II and III, but he provided a clear sonic platform on which James Morris (at 61, a remarkably strong Wotan), Lisa Gasteen (Brünnhilde) and Stephanie Blythe (Fricka) could work their magic. The big nonsurprise surprise was Ms. Blythe, in her first Wagner performance at the Met, once again walking away with the show: the Fricka-Wotan Act II confrontation was actually funny. This woman can do no wrong.

 

ALSO AT THE Met is a new production of Hansel and Gretel, which has been running since Christmas Eve. Instead of Maazelian wisdom and a traditional staging, we have a sleek new production (by Richard Jones, originally for the Welsh National Opera and Lyric Opera of Chicago) and a young (and sleek) conductor, Vladimir Jurowski.

I wish Alan Gilbert all the best as Lorin Maazel’s replacement, but watching Mr. Jurowski put the Met Orchestra through its paces, I couldn’t help but wonder if the New York Phil’s administrators considered hiring this young thoroughbred, who at 36 is the newly appointed principal conductor of the London Philharmonic. Some of the Levine-style luxury came back to the Met ensemble, along with a shimmering palette of woodwind sound—and an inexorable, Tchaikovskian languor—that seemed of Mr. Jurowski’s own conjuring.

If you can have an adult production of Humperdinck’s perennial family favorite, Mr. Jones’ is almost it. Gertrude—Hansel and Gretel’s despairing mother—plays with overdosing on pills; the Sandman (sung with gentleness and poise by a newcomer, the American mezzo Sasha Cooke) is an ugly old crone in a brown raincoat; and John Macfarlane’s curtain drops (a white plate with a smear of blood, a lurid red mouth with a swirl of white teeth about to crunch) aim for the putrescence of a Francis Bacon.

As the starving scamps, the athletic Alice Coote and the lissome Christine Schäfer sang with plenty of personality but consistently mangled their words. Only the great veteran English tenor Philip Langridge, sporting an outrageous fat suit as the Witch, managed to do justice to the King’s English, even when his mouth was full of chocolate and flour.

 

I SHLEPPED ALL the way to Merkin Concert Hall, and all I got was this fancy new lobby. Surely I wasn’t the only member of the city’s classical cognoscenti who muttered those words after being summoned for the cute little gala on Jan. 8 celebrating the hall’s reopening: The auditorium itself, apart from the reupholstered seats, seemed little changed. (In fact, improvements have been made to the mechanical systems, the restrooms and backstage areas.)

The architect, Robert A. M. Stern, New York’s current master of luxe, has given the Kaufman Center a great prow of a marquee jutting on to West 67th Street, and has replaced the cluttered and charmless lobby with something bigger and more glamorous. At least his changes did no harm: The hall’s sound, in a concert ably led by Aaron Jay Kernis—which featured a chamber orchestra and the soprano Esther Heideman performing music by Mr. Kernis and by Aaron Copland—seemed even brighter and more crisp than a year ago.

Time was when Merkin Concert Hall was a place where cutting-edge classical groups performed and ambitious young musicians came to make the scene. The auditorium still hosts a fair number of concerts, but with the ascendancy of Miller Theatre and the arrival of Zankel Hall, it would seem that Merkin’s days as a programming powerhouse are unlikely to return. Yet given the Kaufman Center’s broad cultural mission, that may be no great loss: Places for young people are coveted in the center’s music schools, and as the gala concert closed with a performance by Face the Music, its eager new-music group, we heard that they have plenty of talent of their own.

Russell Platt is a composer and a music editor at The New Yorker. He can be reached at rplatt@observer.com.

Magnetic Personality Disorder

5500 via flickr.com

There are two people's voices I can impersonate well: that of Magnetic Fields frontman Stephin Merritt and Project Runway frontman Tim Gunn. It seems Merritt is forever impersonating as well, or perhaps just exploring the many forms of his beloved pop and rock songcraft. (Alas, Mr. Gunn specializes in another kind of craft, one that falls outside the purview of this review.) Of course this diversity was most prominent on the Magnetic Fields' 1999 compendium 69 Love Songs, for which he and the band ran through nearly every permutation of the love-song conceit, and came to rest on the lucky number.

Yet, while the band has always been a sucker for a blunt conceit, the years since the release of 69 have seen the very bluntness become esoteric. 2004's i was a string-laden soft-pop ode to melodrama where all the songs began with the prime pronoun and were arranged alphabetically. Then there's the string of Mr. Merritt's side-projects, from the guest-vocalist-heavy 6ths to the Gothic Archies' morose children's songs, an accompaniment to the Lemony Snicket Series of Unfortunate Events books. Showtunes was a 2006 collection of Mr. Merritt's work for Chinese theater director Chen Shi-Zeng. Recently Mr. Merritt's voice even graced a Volvo commercial.  read more »

The Ages of Man: Carter, the Gracious Veteran; Dudamel, the Brash Youthman

Elliott Carter’s <i>What Next?</i> at Columbia University’s Miller Theatre.
Elliott Carter’s What Next? at Columbia University’s Miller Theatre.

The most unpleasant experience of modern opera that I’ve ever had came last May at the Spoleto Festival USA in Charleston, N.C., which presented the American premiere of the French composer Pascal Dusapin’s opera Faustus, the Last Night. What plot the opera had was contained in its title: Amid waves of static, senseless music, the knowledge-hoarding ex-philosopher learns from a Beckett-esque character named Togod that, when it comes to all those big questions—the existence of God, the fate of the universe, et al.—the answer is that there is no answer. “There is … NOTHING,” Togod says to us, and in case Faust and the audience don’t get it, he says it very slowly, again and again.

Compared to that, Elliott Carter’s one-act opera, What Next?, which had its New York stage premiere at Columbia University’s Miller Theatre last weekend, was a great improvement, not least because it seems to have an actual story line. It’s just that none of the characters can decide what it should be.

If this vague, postmodern setup, in addition to Mr. Carter’s reputation as a fearsomely intellectual composer, keeps American opera companies from embracing the piece, it would be a shame. Not only is What Next?—by the evidence of Christopher Alden’s light-footed production, and the performance of the assembled cast and of the Juilliard School’s superb Axiom ensemble—actually funny, but it offers some of Mr. Carter’s loveliest and most gracious music. Comparisons to the opera buffas of Mozart would not be inappropriate.

Mr. Carter, whose 99th birthday fell on Dec. 11, writes music that, at its best, balances deep, modernist sophistication with easy, neoclassical lightness. Along with “European” erudition, there’s an “American” intuition, ornery, playful or melancholy by turns—as authentically homegrown as Walt Whitman’s barbaric yawp and Jackson Pollock’s action painting.

What Next? has at least some specifics. (Paul Griffiths, the noted music critic and longtime Carter partisan, wrote the libretto.) Six characters, male and female, adult and child, are reeling from an auto accident, though all seem to be physically unscathed. None can remember how they came to be there, or where they are supposed to be going, and it is from these psychic dislocations that the existential, conversational action of the opera unfolds.

Road workers eventually arrive to clear the scene, but they ignore the other characters—which leads this listener to believe that we’re not at a tight bend in the Lincoln Tunnel (as Andrew Cavanaugh Holland’s set implies) but rather in an eddy of the River Styx.

Even when the music is at its most brittle and violent, Mr. Carter’s vocal lines are limpid, agreeable and elegantly plotted. And they were beautifully sung. Susan Narucki, an experienced soprano who has retained her agile voice and gamine stage presence, led a young cast that included the soprano Amanda Squitieri (who offered some dazzling coloratura singing), the mezzo Katherine Rohrer, the tenor Matthew Garrett and the baritone Morgan Smith—all in strapping vocal health. (The boy alto Jonathan Makepeace gave a knowing and fine performance in his small but crucial role.) Jeffrey Milarsky, an invaluable new-music conductor, led an engaging performance that seemed flawless and firmly expressive.

 

THE STUNNING DISJUNCTION between Mr. Carter’s advanced age and the astonishing youthful vigor of his music was not the only telling contrast on the music scene lately. The New York Philharmonic, long attacked for its stodgy programming and the conservative, veteran conductors it usually employs, got with the program when it brought Gustavo Dudamel—at 26, the most celebrated young conductor in the world, and the new music-director designate of the Los Angeles Philharmonic—onto its podium on Nov. 29.

Tongues have wagged, chiding our orchestra (and the Chicago Symphony) for not snapping up this wunderkind before L.A. did. But a Dudamel regime in New York would amount to a dose of shock therapy that our Philharmonic musicians probably wouldn’t tolerate.

What Mr. Dudamel has to offer in these early days is mostly excitement, but it’s an excitement that comes from living inside the music, not just riding on top of it. And he knows what he wants: a rhythmically explosive sound, fulsomely lyrical but without the caloric richness that Lorin Maazel typically coaxes out of these players.

As the performances of Chávez’s Sinfonía India and Prokofiev’s Fifth Symphony showed, Mr. Dudamel has yet to comprehend the mysteries of musical form—he wouldn’t know a dying fall if it hit him in the head. It was, however, a sign of incipient maturity that he managed to retain his individual leadership style in Dvořák’s Violin Concerto, even while reining it in to accompany the estimable soloist, Gil Shaham—who seemed, by the way, to be having a ball. There’s plenty of time for this conductor to get “interesting”; what’s important is that his talent is true.

 

Russell Platt is a composer and a music editor at The New Yorker. He can be reached at rplatt@observer.com.

Hustler's Rehab: Ghostface Killah's Back (Again!)

Ghostface  performing in October.
Getty Images
Ghostface performing in October.

It was almost a disaster. Ghostface Killah's new album "The Big Doe Rehab" was slated for release today, and by chance so was the latest from Wu-Tang Clan (of which he is a member).

What a pickle! Ghost was upset. The rest of the group was upset. The fans... well they were just excited about the new music. After a few tense days things were set right, so we'll have to wait another week for that Wu-Tang album, but Ghost stands alone, and thank goodness.  read more »

Sir Simon Brings Berlin to Washington Heights

Simon Rattle, music director of the Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra, in 2005.
Simon Rattle, music director of the Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra, in 2005.

That this event came off at all—and it did, with joy and skill and dedication—is a tribute to the hard work and imagination of Clive Gillinson, Carnegie’s executive and artistic director, and his indefatigable colleagues.  read more »

Philip Roth’s Grim Everyman Takes a Bow with Takács

Philip Seymour Hoffman and the Takács Quartet at Zankel Hall.
Julien Jourdes
Philip Seymour Hoffman and the Takács Quartet at Zankel Hall.

The novelist is in the house! He applauds as his words are married to music.  read more »

Toni and Mary Triumph: Opening Night’s Bliss for Opera Buffs

<i>Margaret Garner</i> at City Opera.
Carol Rosegg
Margaret Garner at City Opera.

Margaret Garner is the best new opera that Lincoln Center has heard in quite a while.  read more »

Music in an Almost Classical Mode

Alisa Weilerstein and the Mostly Mozart Festival Orchestra.
Tanit
Alisa Weilerstein and the Mostly Mozart Festival Orchestra.

As you may have noticed, Mostly Mozart isn’t mostly Mozart anymore. If one of the other composers reigns above the rest, it’s Osvaldo Golijov, who manages to generate something like rock-star excitement.
 read more »

Light Summer Classics; a Hearty Russian Ring Cycle

The Kirov Opera in <i>Götterdämmerung</i> at the Met.
Stephanie Berger
The Kirov Opera in Götterdämmerung at the Met.

There’s a great reason to keep the very conservative “Summertime” series going: butts on seats.  read more »

Spring Awakes and Shakes as Boundaries Break Down

Paul Haas conducting the New York Youth Symphony.
Steve J. Sherman
Paul Haas conducting the New York Youth Symphony.

Richard Goode, Alfred Brendel, Maurizio Pollini—a parade of eminent pianists has marched through Carnegie Hall in the last few weeks. But other events this spring remind us that successors to these grand old men are growing up fast.  read more »

Mellowing Jeff Tweedy Trades His Denim for Cords

Good old boys: Tweedy, second from right, and his big, sweet band.
Frank W. Ockenfels
Good old boys: Tweedy, second from right, and his big, sweet band.

On Sky Blue Sky, Wilco’s frontman shows the soft side of his ever-expanding rock band.  read more »

Sleek Wagner, Severe Gluck, Downtown Glass

<i>Tristan und Isolde</i> at Avery Fisher Hall.
Kira Perov
Tristan und Isolde at Avery Fisher Hall.

For many, the operas of Richard Wagner can be a hard slog: The philosophical conundrums of the librettos, the grating consonants of the German language, and the sheer sitzfleisch needed to get through a five-hour show can make a night with Netflix seem suddenly appealing.  read more »

Björk: Still Weird After All These Years

Iceland’s coolest: Björk at Coachella.
Getty Images
Iceland’s coolest: Björk at Coachella.


On Volta, signature wails collide with Timbaland beats Iceland’s coolest: Björk at Coachella.  read more »

Leon Botstein Redefines ‘New’; Benjamin Britten Turns Japanese

Leon Botstein at the podium.
Steve Sherman
Leon Botstein at the podium.

In an age in which a listener can access a thousand years of music with the click of a mouse, and in which living classical composers, no matter how worthy, are unlikely to regain a place at the top of the cultural food chain, just what is “new music” anyway?  read more »

Saturday Night Soundsystem

Cooler than you? LCD Soundsystem
Win Butler
Cooler than you? LCD Soundsystem

James Murphy is portly and uncombed, 37 years old, and drives a 1991 Volvo station wagon.  read more »

Neon Bible: Topical Fairy Tales

Canadians at play: The Montreal septet Arcade Fire.
WIN BUTLER
Canadians at play: The Montreal septet Arcade Fire.

And so this week comes the release of Arcade Fire’s Neon Bible (Merge).    read more »

City Opera’s Bad Boy

G
LIES WALLAERT, OP
G

Toward the end of the 2000 Salzburg Festival, Gérard Mortier, the Belgian impresario whom the  read more »

Older Than Its Own Home, The I.P.O. Marks a Birthday

Gustavo Dudamel, a fast-rising young maestro from Venezuela.
Gustavo Dudamel, a fast-rising young maestro from Venezuela.

“All these great soloists and conductors are family,” said Avi Shoshani, the secretary g  read more »

A Mogul in a Muddle: The Un-Retired Jay-Z

Jay-Z performing last month in Melbourne, Australia.
Kristian Dowling/Getty Images
Jay-Z performing last month in Melbourne, Australia.

On what was supposed to have been his last album ever, Jay-Z made a little joke: “When I come  read more »

Handsome, Athletic Tenor, Hungry for Superstardom

A Peruvian paragon: Juan Diego Fl
Ken Howard/Metropolitan Opera
A Peruvian paragon: Juan Diego Fl

“He’s got everything I encourage my students to aspire to,” Marilyn Horne said to  read more »

A Mogul in a Muddle: The Un-Retired Jay-Z

On what was supposed to have been his last album ever, Jay-Z made a little joke: “When I come back  read more »

Handsome, Athletic Tenor, Hungry for Superstardom

“He’s got everything I encourage my students to aspire to,” Marilyn Horne said to me a few wee  read more »

Another Side of Bob Dylan: A Chorus of Inventive Covers

Cat Power performing at <i>The Music of Bob Dylan</i> at Avery Fisher Hall.
Michael Priest
Cat Power performing at The Music of Bob Dylan at Avery Fisher Hall.

When the dozy, dreamy singer-songwriter Cat Power walked onstage at last week’s “The Mus  read more »

Another Side of Bob Dylan: A Chorus of Inventive Covers

When the dozy, dreamy singer-songwriter Cat Power walked onstage at last week’s “The Music of Bo  read more »

Blessed Beacon From Peru Lights Up C.M.J. Festival

Something like 1,138 bands played all over New York during last week’s 26th annual College Music J  read more »

Blessed Beacon From Peru Lights Up C.M.J. Festival

Susan Baca
Susan Baca

Something like 1,138 bands played all over New York during last week’s 26th annual College Mus  read more »

Upbeat, Warm and Sunny, A Band Bids Angst Adieu

The Hold Steady’s second album, Separation Sunday, starts late at night, in a quiet, dirty room.  read more »

Upbeat, Warm and Sunny, A Band Bids Angst Adieu

The pride of Brooklyn: the Hold Steady.
The pride of Brooklyn: the Hold Steady.

The Hold Steady’s second album, Separation Sunday, starts late at night, in a quiet, dirty roo  read more »

Carnegie Hosts a Duel; Cleveland Honors Bruckner

Question: What does cutting-edge classical music have in common with cancer drugs?  read more »

Carnegie Hosts a Duel; Cleveland Honors Bruckner

Question: What does cutting-edge classical music have in common with cancer drugs?  read more »

Madama for the Masses; Ponchielli for Night Owls

Anthony Minghella
Ken Howard/Metropolitan Opera
Anthony Minghella

On opening night, a red carpet led operagoers Oscar-style across the Lincoln Center Plaza.  read more »

Madama for the Masses; Ponchielli for Night Owls

On opening night, a red carpet led operagoers Oscar-style across the Lincoln Center Plaza.  read more »

Who Owns Lenny Bernstein? A Musical Legacy Gone Global

Leonard Bernstein, a polyglot
Central Press/Getty Images
Leonard Bernstein, a polyglot

Forget the baseball rivalry: The real Boston–New York dispute is over bragging rights to Leona  read more »

Who Owns Lenny Bernstein? A Musical Legacy Gone Global

Forget the baseball rivalry: The real Boston–New York dispute is over bragging rights to Leonard B  read more »

Lovelorn Will Oldham; Ambient Album Leaf

Will Oldham, a.k.a Bonnie
Steve Gullick
Will Oldham, a.k.a Bonnie

A chorus on Bonnie “Prince” Billy’s new record, The Letting Go (Drag City), begins  read more »

Lovelorn Will Oldham; Ambient Album Leaf

A chorus on Bonnie “Prince” Billy’s new record, The Letting Go (Drag City), begins with a fami  read more »

When Sexy Met Indie: Junior Boys Grow Up Fast

There
www.juniorboys.net
There

Let’s assume for the moment that today’s “independent” music scene is an aes  read more »

When Sexy Met Indie: Junior Boys Grow Up Fast

Let’s assume for the moment that today’s “independent” music scene is an aesthetically—or  read more »

A Music Critic Performs, Practices What He Preaches

One of the most characterful presences at musical events over the past several decades—once se  read more »

A Music Critic Performs, Practices What He Preaches

One of the most characterful presences at musical events over the pa