Baruch Goldstein

Israel Is In Crisis. Or, How Violence Shapes Identity in the Middle East

Last night in a conference room at Columbia's School of International and Public Affairs, 20 students gathered to hear a young Palestinian woman and a former Israeli soldier, sitting side by side under the auspices of the peace organization One Voice, tell of the situation in Israel/Palestine. At the end, the two, who had politely disagreed about a number of issues, were asked for a final statement about their hopes. The Palestinian, who had long dark hair and a downward gaze, said, "It's not necessarily about hope. It's about not wanting another best friend to die. It makes me tremble just to think about that. And I decide that I cannot shape a Palestinian identity around violence. So it's really about compromise. It's not about hope."

The former Israeli soldier, blue-eyed, his shirt sleeves pushed up around his biceps, said, "In Hebrew we have a word, Amal. It means, I have nothing to add. I agree with her completely."

(I am sorry not to have these young people's names; I got there late; I will supply them later.)

The news from Israel/Palestine these days is desperate. For the second time in a few months an "errant" Israeli mortar shell has destroyed an innocent Palestinian family in Gaza—  read more »